This post contains affiliate links. Book Riot can earn a commission when you buy through these links.

Happy Mystery Month! May was the month when the love of mystery was expressed, also because Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s birthday falls on the 22nd. Whether your taste for mystery is die-hard, leisurely, true crime, or more thriller, let’s celebrate Mystery Month with a roundup of cute literary gifts for mystery lovers.

Pins, stickers, and other literary gifts for mystery lovers

Slip this mysterious bunch of keys on your keys and you will never wonder where they went. $ 15.

Keep Agatha Christie close to anything you read with this magnetic bookmark. $ 4.

Put on an enamel lapel pin for mystery readers. $ 11.

If you’re more of a real crime reader, never fear. There’s a cute enamel lapel pin for you too. $ 11.

Slip on a pair of Nancy Drew earrings and pay homage to one of the best teenagers in literature. $ 15.

Curl up with a good book and this cozy mystery candle. $ 14 and above.

What could be nicer than waking up than enjoying the caffeinated drink of your choice in a real crime mug? $ 20 and more.

Exactly right, Thelma. Attract this mysterious queen to your favorite bag or jacket. $ 3.

This mystery reader sticker would look great anywhere you hit it. $ 3.

A personalized Sherlock Holmes bottle is a great reading companion. $ 17 and above.

And this Sherlock hoodie has a handy storage pocket for the bottle mentioned above, if that’s what you want. $ 33 and above.

How well would you solve this Nancy Drew puzzle? This tea is $ 23.

Hang this mystery genre poster in your study. $ 14 and above.

Don’t crawl. Scrabble! How much fun is this mysterious mug? $ 20.

Once you’ve found literary gifts for mystery lovers, you’ll want to familiarize yourself with some feminist mysteries, some excellent cozy mysteries, and these historical mystery series.